TESTIMONIALS

Honesty is a big word. She could not get me a lower rate because of an accident on my record and she told me the truth. She was able to get my mother a way better rate. 10 star rating all I can say. She is polite and very intelligent woman.

This was probably my best experience with a business professional—she was courteous, punctual, and always kept her promises. I definitely plan to use this place again and again!

Very easy to work with and quick response time! Easiest process I’ve ever had with getting insurance!

Jessica was amazing! She was able to find an even lower rate for my car insurance than expected. She was so helpful. It is a relief to have such awesome help because on my own I was stressed trying to get a good rate. Thank you so much for your support!

I had a wonderful experience switching my car insurance! Steph went above and beyond, even squeezing me in over the weekend outside of regular business hours to accommodate my needs. She found me a phenomenal rate, and her customer service was truly top-notch. I highly recommend Steph to anyone looking for great coverage, excellent rates, and exceptional service!

stephanie is PHENOMENAL! she is always here to help absolutely whenever i need her, and is always looking for the best for me. im so thankful for her!!

Stephanie took the time to find me the best rate and was also able to adjust my coverage based on my current needs. I appreciate her honesty, taking the time to listen to what I had to say and explaining things when I had questions.

Stephanie was very thorough in finding the best insurance plans to fit our family’s needs. She saved us a ton of money and was so great to work with!

If you are looking to save some money on your home and auto give Steph a call. She saved us over 30% from what we were paying! She reviewed our policies with us to ensure we were getting the same and in some cases even better coverage than what we had. She is extremely knowledgeable and friendly. You would be crazy not to give her call and see what she can do for you!

Stephanie has been great to work with! Very personable and she was able to get us great rates on insurance, and saving money!! Would highly recommend!!

I enjoyed the service, I enjoyed the conversation, enjoyed how she got me the prices and the insurance that I exactly wanted. And and when business was settled I felt a sense of relief and happiness for what I agree to. Thank you Stephanie.

Stephanie was very nice and helpful with the process

Stephanie was very knowledgeable and explained everything in detail about the insurance we were buying. I highly recommend her as an insurance agent.

Very knowledgeable and great to work with.

No comment available

Stephanie was great! She made the process so easy!

Very quick and easy to deal with and got me a really great price

Stephanie was very responsive to my request for motorcycle insurance. Our rate doubled from 2025 to 2026 even with a clean driving record. She was able to cut that rate in half, keeping the same coverages. Highly recommend!

my first time getting insurance was SO nerve racking as a fresh 21 year old but she mad it so so easy and did the hard stuff for me 🙌🏼 and the price is very similar to what i switched from so it’s perfect !!!

Very helpful & knowledgeable and really made sure we understood everything. Highly recommend Stephane Maluchnik Insurance

Stephanie at McCaffrey Insurance was extremely helpful. She explained all my questions about our homeowners & auto insurance policies. I especially appreciated her flexibility to work with my changing schedule while finding the best policies for us - THANKS Stephanie!

Stephanie was extremely helpful in explaining our insurance options and finding the best coverage for our needs without rushing us through the process. She was readily available and accommodating. We would definitely recommend her to family and friends.

Stephanie was exceptionally helpful and patient with helping us obtain better insurance with a much better price . Will recommend her for anyone needing insurance.

Stephanie was phenomenal with setting up our property insurance! We had a mishap and needed something immediately - she had it buttoned up and in place in less than 24 hrs! Highly recommend.

The BEST agency to deal with your insurance needs! Stephanie was able to match my current coverages at almost 50% off of what I was currently paying. Not to mention a fast response and pleasant to deal with! Could not ask for a better experience!

Great experience. Friendly, fast and easy to work with.

Stephanie went above and beyond to help me secure coverage. She was so kind and before I knew it I was safe to be on the road. There's no other way to handle all your insurance needs with McCaffrey of Johnstown insurance Inc!!!

Steph was great and peronsable. She personally visited us to discuss our options. Went to her office to sign everything and had a worrisome free experience. Highly Recommend!!!!

Great service!!! Saved a ton of money with this agency. Steph is incredible and is always there to answer questions or help in any way.

I want to acknowledge my heartfelt appreciation for Stephanie, whose extraordinary dedication, compassion, and unwavering commitment to her customers truly set her apart. It is rare to encounter someone who not only excels in their profession but also pours so much of themselves—their heart, strength, and character—into everything they do. Stephanie is one of those exceptional individuals. What makes her remarkable is not just her expertise, though her knowledge of insurance is exceptional. It is the way she shows up for people. Every customer she meets is treated with kindness, respect, and genuine care. She listens with empathy, responds with patience, and works tirelessly to ensure every person feels supported and valued. Her heart is as big as her work ethic, and she never hesitates to go above and beyond. One example speaks volumes about who she is: she stepped in to help a customer that other insurance agencies had turned away. Rather than seeing a challenge, she saw a person in need. She went outside the scope of her normal duties, dedicating her time and energy to make sure that individual received the support they deserved. Her actions were not only compassionate—they were transformative. Beyond her daily service, Stephanie is a strong woman who never gives up. Owning and growing a new insurance agency is not easy—it demands resilience, courage, long hours, and a determination that many people don’t see. But she faces every challenge head-on, driven by her love for her customers and her commitment to doing what is right. Her perseverance is inspiring, and her strength is evident in every aspect of her business. She is also a tremendous asset to her community—not only through her work as an agent, but through her unwavering support of small businesses. She is constantly lifting them up, celebrating their achievements, and giving them recognition whenever she can. Her dedication to helping others succeed extends far beyond her own office, creating a ripple effect of positivity and connection throughout the community. I want her to receive every bit of recognition she has earned—not only because she deserves it, but because her business deserves to grow and flourish in the hands of someone with her integrity, compassion, and tenacity. She is the kind of leader and professional our community needs, and the kind of person any organization would be proud to stand behind. Stephanie truly represents the very best of this industry. I am deeply grateful for all that Stephanie does and honored to recognize her for the remarkable impact she makes every day.

I was shopping with multiple insurance agencies. Steph took the time to sit down with me and really dig deep into what my insurance needs were. We were able to weed through what I really need v what I don’t actually need. She was able to save me a large sum of money for my insurance expenses. Steph is the best. Excellent, prompt communication, and attention to details, very knowledgeable in her field. I’m very satisfied with my experience at McCaffery Insurance.

Stephanie is awesome! She got me a great deal on my house insurance and showed me savings for bundling my car insurance as well. If you need insurance, don't go anywhere else!!

No comment available

It never hurts to get a quote on insurance, I’m really glad I did , I have a camper , motorcycles, home , auto and a boat , I thought switching insurance would be a hassle, Stephanie McCaffrey made it quick and easy and saved me a couple thousand per year. I highly recommend her.

Steph was so helpful and really tentative to all of my insurance questions. Ultimately saving us well over $200 on our auto policy. Super thankful we made the switch!

Stephanie is the BEST AGENT EVER. Anything that I need she is ALWAYS there for me, my business and my family. Excellent service always.

No comment available

No comment available

No comment available

Very helpful in finding me the right insurance prices and got it done in a timely manner.

Stephanie does an outstanding work. She finds the best insurance that works for everyone.

I appreciate the time Stephanie took to find the best rates. I feel that she is honest, gives good information, and really there to help the customer.

I can’t thank Stephanie enough for her help and patience. She was kind, honest, and incredibly supportive during what could have been a stressful process. She made everything easy to understand and truly had my best interests in mind. I would recommend her to anyone without hesitation.

Steph was fantastic to deal with. The rates were lower than what I have been paying from another company. She made the process so easy and fast!!!

Excellent service

Stephanie is the best, she really helps you find the best insurance rates! I highly recommend!

No comment available

Top notch level. This woman is amazing. I called for a quote and she let me know that my company has hung me out to dry. The agent just left not notifying or helping his customers. Stephanie did a lot of work to help me get in a policy that would help and save quite a bit. She goes the extra mile for her customers. They aren't just numbers.. she puts all she can into helping the customer. That type of customer service isn't seen anymore and why she is a true gem. Thank you

McCaffrey Insurance has been amazing! Before I switched to Stephanie at McCaffrey Insurance my premiums kept going up. My old agent never did anything to help find me lower rate options. When I called McCaffrey's the went to work without hesitation to find us better rates. So grateful for Stephanie and her hard work.

Steph was the kindest and most caring person I dealt with. She handled my situation very professional.