top of page

TESTIMONIALS

We'd love to hear
about your experience.

We pride ourselves in the levels of service we provide. Please let us know how we're doing and if there's ever anything that we can do to improve your experience in your coverage selection journey.

WHAT CUSTOMERS ARE SAYING.

KIND WORDS
FROM OUR
CLIENTS

Dave Rykala

Oct 3, 2025

Singer on Stage
Very knowledgeable. Went the extra mile to secure good coverage at a good price

Josh

Oct 3, 2025

Singer on Stage
No comment available

Lori Horner

Oct 3, 2025

Singer on Stage
No comment available

lee ashcom

Oct 3, 2025

Singer on Stage
Steph at McCaffrey insurance is the best. She got me cheaper car insurance and I totally recommend her if you need anything. So nice to talk to and everything

Tammy Stevens

Oct 2, 2025

Singer on Stage
Fast ..friendly affordable insurance and service.. always a smiling face..highly recommend

Bobbie Salem

Sep 25, 2025

Singer on Stage
Great agent and staff

Jacob Conzatti

Sep 23, 2025

Singer on Stage
Very friendly and easy to deal with. Always a phone call away for help. Would recommend

Karen Yurkovich

Sep 21, 2025

Singer on Stage
I appreciate that at MCCAFFREY insurance agency you see a familiar face and when you call, you get a local voice, not a stranger at a call center. Stephanie is known in our community in a "Positive" way and gets involved in community events. She supports small business whenever possible. At MCCAFFREY, you're not just another policy number, you are a friend! Steph takes the time to get to know you and your family. She knows you on a personal level and helps to ensure the best coverage for your needs. Even when things get tough, she gets tougher and manages to easily work you through it. Steph is strong, committed and devoted to her clients. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND STEPHANIE AND MCCAFFREY for all your insurance needs .

Lilly Oakes

Sep 19, 2025

Singer on Stage
The staff is very friendly and helpful. The environment is clean and welcoming!

Ally Lonas

Sep 18, 2025

Singer on Stage
I cannot say enough about Steph at McCaffrey. She is absolutely the best! From my very first experience with her, she made me feel like a priority. Her responsiveness is unmatched and she is always quick to answer questions and make sure I’m taken care of. Whenever I’ve had issues, Steph was right there and because of her I never felt stressed. Being someone that works a lot, this is truly appreciated. What impresses me most is how she looks out for her clients’ best interests. You can tell she truly cares and goes above and beyond to make sure everything is handled properly. It’s rare to find someone so professional yet so personable. I am beyond grateful for all that Steph has done. I’d highly recommend her and her company to anyone.

chuck chestnutwood

Sep 17, 2025

Singer on Stage
Super personalized attention.

Aaron Callihan

Sep 17, 2025

Singer on Stage
No comment available

Jennifer Strayer

Sep 17, 2025

Singer on Stage
Very helpful. Fantastic experience. Made it very easy to get the right insurance to fit my needs.

Tonya Bambino

Sep 17, 2025

Singer on Stage
Steph is great to work with! She gets back to any of my questions immediately and is very thorough explaining everything that I need to know about what is going on with my claims if I have any!

Nathan Brezensky

Sep 17, 2025

Singer on Stage
The service at McCaffrey Insurance is phenomenal. I had home and auto bundled with another company and thought I was saving money until I had McCaffrey quote me. I ended up saving over $1000 a year. You won’t find anyone the works hard to get you the best rate and service. They treat you like family. I would recommend them to anyone.

Barry Hostetler

Sep 17, 2025

Singer on Stage
Exceptional Customer Service !!

Nhoffer67

Sep 16, 2025

Singer on Stage
No comment available

charles conzatti

Sep 16, 2025

Singer on Stage
Steff is one of the hardest working agents I’ve known. She does great work!

Dan Bessemer

Sep 16, 2025

Singer on Stage
Amazing customer service and blown away by the promptness of service needs

Ashley Callihan

Sep 16, 2025

Singer on Stage
Steph and her staff have been nothing but reliable and helpful! They take the time to make sure that I fully understand my policies and always answer any question I have. They are so kind and so easy to work with!

Ryan Fondelier

Sep 16, 2025

Singer on Stage
Stephanie is amazing and treats her clients like family.

Amy Dunmyer

Sep 16, 2025

Singer on Stage
Our absolute favorite Agency! Stephanie is top-notch.

William

Sep 16, 2025

Singer on Stage
I highly recommend McCaffrey Ins for your insurance needs. Stephanie is willing to work with her clients to get them the best coverage.

Darla Meyers

Sep 16, 2025

Singer on Stage
Steph is always friendly and helpful!!!

Scott Lohr

Sep 16, 2025

Singer on Stage
Great agent. Good quotes and insurance.

Christie Yingling

Aug 29, 2025

Singer on Stage
Steph is one of the most amazing agents. She takes care of her accounts and educates her customers on all aspects of claims and their policies.

Jacinda Fondelier

Jul 23, 2025

Singer on Stage
Stephanie is really knowledgeable and will find the right coverage to meet your needs. She genuinely cares about her customers.

Amie Held

Jul 13, 2025

Singer on Stage
No comment available
bottom of page